Menus
Tuesday - Thursday
5:30pm – 11:00pm
Friday - Saturday
5:30pm - 12:00am
Sunday
5:30pm - 10:00pm
Snacks
$6-
Deviled Eggs
crispy capers, white anchovy
-
Pig's Foot Croquettes
apple ketchup
-
Smoked Olives
pickled celery
Charcuterie
$9 each, or three for $26-
Meat
all with house-baked sourdough
Saucisson Sec
'Nduja
Landjaeger
-
Fish
all with house-made saltines
Smoked Whitefish
Cured Arctic Char
Pickled Mackerel
Plates
-
Whipped Labneh
mint, honey
$9
-
Market Green Salad
ewe's milk cheese
$13
-
Roasted Pumpkin
fresh cheese, hazelnuts
$14
-
Beef Tongue Salad
mustard vinaigrette
$15
-
Beef Tartare & Bottarga
beef drippings, toast
$15
-
Grilled Flatbread
wild mushrooms, egg yolk
$16
Mains
-
Glazed Lamb Ribs
yogurt, shallot
$18
-
Duck Breast
fig, chanterelles
$28
-
Skate Wing
smoked tomatoes, sherry beurre blanc
$24
-
Cheeseburger & Fries
double, grass-fed, pickles, fermented chilis, aioli
$20
-
Ribeye for Two
roasted bone marrow, hollandaise
$108
Dessert
-
Quince & Cream
earl grey meringue
$10
-
Chocolate Tart
honey, sea salt
$10
-
OddFellows Ice Cream
Choice of two scoops
$6
-
Cheese
Stilton, Mrs. Quicke's Cheddar, Morn Dew
Each roll $8
All three for $26
-
Coffee
Espresso $3
Macchiato $3.50
Cortado $4
Capuccino $4.50
Latte $5
Cold brew can $5
-
Tea
Teas by In Pursuit of Tea
Saturday - Sunday
11:00am - 4:00pm
House-Made Pastries
-
Doughnut
vanilla cream, lemon zest sugar
$5
-
Toasted Focaccia
strawberry & elderflower jam
$5
-
Sticky Bun
peach compote, dried currants
$6
-
Sourdough Croissant
plum conserva
$5
-
Steel-Cut Granola
whipped yogurt, fig compote, honey
$9
-
Custard French Toast
tristar strawberries, whipped cream
$12
East Coast Oysters
on the half shell, with pickle brunoise, citrus mignonette & house hot sauce-
$3
Plates and Sandwiches
-
Deviled Eggs
crispy capers, white anchovy
$6
-
Avocado Toast
dill vinegar, ancho chilis, oro antico cheese
$11
bacon $4
poached eggs $4
-
Market Green Salad
ewe's milk cheese
$13
-
Admiral's Board
whitefish salad, pickled mackerel, and cured arctic char served with labneh, crispy capers, soft scrambled eggs, grilled bread
$32
-
Grilled Bacon & Fried Eggs
roasted heirloom tomato, buttered toast
$18
-
Duck Hash
poached eggs, confit duck, buttered toast
$15
-
Breakfast Sandwich
egg, sausage, strong cheese, fermented chilis
$12
-
Cheeseburger
double, grass-fed, pickles, fermented chilis, aioli
$16
-
Fries $6
House-made Sausage $5
Side salad $5
Sourdough Toast $2
Served all day
Specialty Cocktails
$13-
Cherry Point Sour
smoked scotch, fresh lemon, splash Bordeaux, shaken, on the rocks
-
Fitzgerald
London dry gin, fresh lemon, angostura bitters, shaken, straight up
-
Soul Retriever
tequila, hibiscus, maraschino, fresh lemon, mint, on crushed ice
-
Thinking Cap
bourbon old fashioned with house made root beer bitters stirred, on the rocks
-
Caribbean Motion
Guyanese rum, marjoram, honey, lime, sparkling wine, shaken, straight up
The 'Tinis
-
Martini
Regular size $13
Mighty $17
-
Manhattan
Regular size $13
Mighty $17
-
Rob Roy
Regular size $13
Mighty $17
Day Drinking
-
Bloody Mary
vodka, habanero, anchovy stuffed olive
$11
-
Manhattan Avenue Spritz
Contratto, hopped grapefruit bitters, sparkling wine
$12
-
Cherry Point Sour
smoked scotch. fresh lemon, splash of Bordeaux shaken, on the rocks
$13
-
Soul Retriever
tequila, hibiscus, maraschino, fresh lemon, mint, on crushed ice
$13
Sherry
-
Manzanilla
"La Cigarrera," (NV) Andalucia, Spain
$7
-
Amontillado
Bodegas Grant, La Garrocha (NV) ANdalucia, Spain
$7
Draft Beer
-
Catskill Ball Lightning Pilsner
$8
-
Bell's Oberon Ale
$8
-
Founders Oatmeal Stout
$8
-
Greenport Harbor IPA
$8
Bottled and Canned Beer
-
Budweiser
$5
-
Augustiner Bräu Munchen Lager
$7
-
Rothas Pilsner
$8
-
Gaffel Kölsch
$7
-
Peekskill Simple Soar
(16 oz)
$6
-
La Chouffe
$10
-
Cigar City Jai Alai IPA
$6
-
Wolffer Estate Dry Rosé Cider
10 oz
$8
-
Austin East Cider
$5
-
Tripel Karmeleit
25.4 oz big bottle
$34
Housemade Sodas
-
Wild Ginger Beer
$6
-
Natural Root Beer
$6
-
La Colombe Coffee
-
In Pursuit of Teas
All of our wines are thoughtfully chosen from unique, independent producers. Our list offers many organic, biodynamic, natural and traditional options. Please note that our list changes often and our exact offerings my differ slightly from this list.
Sparkling
-
Paleokerisio
Domaine Gilnavos 2015 (debina) - Zitsa, Greece (orange - 500ml bottle)
glass $10
bottle $28
-
Cava
Mestres 1312 (NV) - Catalonia, Spain
glass $12
bottle $36
-
Lambrusco
Azienda Crocizia "Marc Aurelio" 2015 - Emilia, Italy
$43
-
Blonde
Andrea Calek 2016 (viognier) - Rhone Valley, France
$59
-
Crémant d'Alsace
Pierre Frick "Amplitude Reserve" 2014 - Alsace, France
$65
White
-
Dry Riesling
Stein "Weihwasser" 2016 - Mosel, Germany
glass $11
carafe $26
bottle $36
-
Quantum Winery
Weiss Ein Quantum Weinviertel 2017 (field blend) - Niederösterreich, Austria
$51
-
Populis
"Wabi-Sabi" 2017 (Sauvignon Blanc, Chardonnay, Colombard) - Mendocino County, California
$46
-
Malvar
Bodegas Marc Isart "La Maldición" 2017 - Madrid, Spain
$45
-
Picpoul de Pinet
Julie Benau 2017 - Languedoc, France
glass $11
carafe $26
bottle $36
-
Muscadet
Chateau-Thebaud "Clos des Morines" 2012 (melon) - Loire, France
$49
-
Saumur
Manoir de la Tête Rouge 2016 (chenin blanc) - Loire, France
$45
-
Chablis
Romain et Damien Bouchard "Domaine de l'Enclos" 2016 (chardonnay) - Burgundy, France
$54
-
Pinot Blanc
Leon Boesch "La Cabane" 2015 - Alsace, France
glass $14
carafe $35
bottle $42
-
Albariño
"Pedralonga" 2016 - Rias Baixas, Spain
$57
Rose
-
Côtes de Toul
Migot "Vin Gris" 2017 (gamay, pinot noir) - Lorraine, France
glass $14
carafe $35
bottle $41
Cider
-
Aaron Burr "Summitville"
Homestead Cider (Sullivan County Apples) - Sullivan County, NY 7.8% ABV (500ml bottle)
$39
-
Fey Apple Wine
Enlightenment Wines (Hudson Valley apples, wildflower honey) - NY, NY 12.5% ABV (750ml bottle)
$50
Red
-
Conca de Barberà
Lectores Vini "Pomagrana" 2017 (trepat) - Catalonia, Spain
bottle $42
-
Pineau d'Aunis
Brendan Tracey 2016 - Loire, France
$66
-
Beaujolais
Marcel Joubert "Cuvée Å L"Ancienne" 2016 (gamay) - Beaujolais, France
glass $13
carafe $32
bottle $40
-
Beaujolais
Nathalie Banes "La Saolée" 2015 (gamay) - Beaujolais, France
$51
-
Morgon
Anthony Thevenet 2016 (gamay) - Beaujolais, France
$46
-
Touraine
Clos du Tue-Boeuf "La Butte" 2017 (gamay) - Loire Valley, France
$47
-
Chinon
Olga Raffault, “Les Picasses” 2013 (cabernet franc) - Loire, France
$62
-
Pinot Noir
Enderle & Moll, “Basis” 2016 - Baden, Germany
$54
-
Pinot Noir
Domaine Maison en Belles Lies, “Maranges” 2015 - Burgundy, France
$88
-
Listan Negro
Tajinaste, Tinto Tradicional 2016 - Canary Islands, Spain
glass $12
carafe $29
bottle $45
-
Limniona
Domaine Zafeirakis 2015 - Thessaly, Greece
$54
-
Cabernet Franc
Mylan Wines 2017 - Moody-Tollbridge Vineyard, Columbia Gorge AVA
$70
-
Cahors
Parlange & Illouz "La Piéce" 2015 (malbec) - Cahors, France
glass $16
carafe $41
bottle $51
-
Babiole
Andrea Calek 2016 (syrah, carignan, grenache) - Rhone Valley, France
$45
-
Chateauneuf-du-Pape
Roger Perrin "Les Galets de la Berthaude" 2016 (grenache, syrah, mourvedre) - Rhone Valley, France
$63
-
Laderes de Sedella
2014 (garnacha, jaén, romé) - Andalucîa, Spain
glass $13
carafe $32
bottle $40
-
Cabernet Sauvignon
Ian Brand "Le P'tit Paysan" 2016 - Central Coast, California
$60
Sherry
-
Manzanilla
"La Cigarrera," (NV) Andalucia, Spain
$7
-
Amantillado
Bodegas Grant, La Garrocha (NV) Andalucia, Spain
$7
Mead
-
Raise the Roof
Enlightenment Wines (sour culture, apple blossom honey, well water, wild yeast) - NY, NY 12.5% ABV (750ml bottle)
$59
Tuesday - Friday
5:30pm - 7:00pm
Butcher's Snacks
$7 each-
Pickled Mackerel
Pickled carrot
-
'Nduja
Honey, toast
-
Dry-Cured Saucisson
Pickles, half deviled egg
Drinks
$7 each-
Chilled Aquavit
-
Sangiovese
Scopa, Tuscany, Italy
-
Vinho Verde
Portugal
'Tinis!
$8 each-
Martini
-
Manhattan
-
Rob Roy
Snacks
-
Deviled Eggs
Fried capers, white anchovy
$6
-
Smoked Olives
Pickled celery
$6
-
Whipped Labneh
Mint, honey
$9